Superfreakonomics was a great read. Every chapter was fascinating, apart from the one about the "birthday bulge", which I have read about again and again in similar texts, including one of Malcolm Gladwell's. The concept is that child athletes that succeed almost always have fall birthdays. Among a grade of students, those who are born in September or October are significantly older than their peers born in July or August. For children even an age difference of eleven months can provide a significant edge in development. So let's say you take a group of fifth grade hockey players. The ones with fall birthdays may be stronger and farther along in puberty than the ones born in the summer, so they get ranked better and that causes an ongoing advantage in the sport. It is much more eloquently stated in the book, but I hope I least made some sense
My favourite chapter was on why suicide bombers should buy life insurance. It discussed an algorithm created by a British banker to detect terrorists. There are many factors that can indicate someone is a terrorist I was a bit infuriated that the main factor was whether or not someone had a Muslim name. Many terrorist organization purposely seek out people with Western names, such as David Headly who organized the Bombay attacks, so I found it a bit ignorant they didn't take that into account. As much as I hate racial profiling, I got over it and kept reading. There were other factors that people expected to have an effect that didn't, for example it didn't matter how close a person lived to a mosque. Using a wide range of variables, including one that had to remain unnamed for national security reasons, they made a very accurate algorithm for detecting terrorists. One of the factors was whether or not someone had life insurance. Now it may seem like someone who was about to kill themselves would want life insurance, but we must remember that a. insurance companies do not cover suicide bombings and b. almost all terrorists are young men with no families. If a terrorist were to buy life insurance, they could easily fly under the radar of this algorithm. Why they didn't have to keep this a secret, I do not know, seems silly to explain the algorithm in any sort of detail in a best-selling book, but it did make for a fascinating read.
Now that I am done with Superfreakonomics, I've decided to take a different turn. I will not be reading fiction, even though I do miss it a bit. Instead I've decided to embark on a journey my mother did many years ago. I'm going to attempt to read all the religious texts of major world religions. I'm starting with the Quran. Although Islam has made it very clear that the Quran should be read by followers in its original Arabic, I have not learned Arabic yet (it's on my bucket list though) and will be reading an English translation that seems to be universally praised. One thing that sets the Quran apart from the Bible is that if you read it in English, it has only been translated once and therefore retains much of its original meaning. People forget the Bible has been translated hundreds of times, and I am sure this has caused confusion and alterations.
Islam has always been an important part of my life. Many of my parents' friends are Muslim and as a child we travelled through the Middle East. I was also mentored by a Muslim vet I volunteered for, and he taught me so much about Islam and life in general. My mother's friend Lubna Al Qasimi is a member of the royal family in the UAE and the country's first woman minister. Despite breaking down gender roles found in her culture, she has remained religious. My mother has benefitted greatly from reading the Quran. She has a greater understanding of where her friends come from, and has been able to successfully shut down Islamophobic idiots by directly quoting the Quran. I can't wait to someday be able to do the same!
This all sounds really interesting, and I'm glad I was assigned to comment on your blog. I actually never knew about the "birthday bulge", though now hearing it, it does make sense. Do you think the theory is applicable to ages older than middle school? I feel that this does make a significant difference when looking at kids going through puberty, but I think it is a different story when kids reach high school and have all gone through puberty. I feel most athletes are equal in that sense, especially in high school when athletes are placed in a level of sport based on qualifications rather than age. The chapter about suicide bombers buying life insurance sounds really cool. I never would have thought that someone developed an algorithm for determining someone a terrorist or not. If the algorithm proves successful, I'm sure it will be a tool gaining steam in the years to come. But after reading your post, I don't think it is 100% accurate, at least not yet. I agree that racial profiling should not be used in this context, or at all, and it makes it seem that the developer of this algorithm is almost closed-minded in a way. I think it is really cool that you plan to read the religious text from major religions. I can really tell that you like to know a little bit about everything- something you said in one of your previous blogs- if you plan to embark on reading them all. Honestly, I would like to do this as well, but if every text is as long as the bible, I highly doubt I would be able to get through even half of one text. You seemed determined, and I wish you luck on your endeavor.
ReplyDeleteThis all sounds really interesting, and I'm glad I was assigned to comment on your blog. I actually never knew about the "birthday bulge", though now hearing it, it does make sense. Do you think the theory is applicable to ages older than middle school? I feel that this does make a significant difference when looking at kids going through puberty, but I think it is a different story when kids reach high school and have all gone through puberty. I feel most athletes are equal in that sense, especially in high school when athletes are placed in a level of sport based on qualifications rather than age. The chapter about suicide bombers buying life insurance sounds really cool. I never would have thought that someone developed an algorithm for determining someone a terrorist or not. If the algorithm proves successful, I'm sure it will be a tool gaining steam in the years to come. But after reading your post, I don't think it is 100% accurate, at least not yet. I agree that racial profiling should not be used in this context, or at all, and it makes it seem that the developer of this algorithm is almost closed-minded in a way. I think it is really cool that you plan to read the religious text from major religions. I can really tell that you like to know a little bit about everything- something you said in one of your previous blogs- if you plan to embark on reading them all. Honestly, I would like to do this as well, but if every text is as long as the bible, I highly doubt I would be able to get through even half of one text. You seemed determined, and I wish you luck on your endeavor.
ReplyDeleteWow, this sounds like our kind of book! And haha, I know Asha, I think I spent a full page in one of my blogs trying to explain the birthday bulge idea, but I get it. I think that is a very cool concept.
ReplyDeleteAnd wow, the whole racial profiling things seems pretty ignorant, but I am glad you could move past it, and not let it sour the book for you.
Also, you have made an ambitious and commendable goal. I think that is super awesome! I love that you are reading texts that connect to your life. Not only are you reading like a writer, but you are reading like someone who wants to be a better, more knowledgeable, more informed, more understanding, more connected Asha.
(yes, I'm super late on commenting)
ReplyDeleteStarting, with the "birthday bulge", I didn't know that was an actual thing but I totally know what you were talking about. I just turned seventeen in July and I hate that I won't be eighteen until before I head off to college, It's just always made me feel weird and young compared to my friends. I actually think that it's a good thing that you were able to feel such a range of emotions while reading. You mentioned that the racial profiling made you angry and I wonder if the author did this purposely to make his readers feel a certain way or do they just suck.
Now, the goal of reading all of the religious texts is pretty awesome. If there is one person I'd put my money on to complete this, no doubt it would be you.
Good luck on your reading!!!
I admire the fact that you’ve read a book that you feel so strong about. It seems that people now in days especially teen aren’t taking advantage of the written word. The fact that you’ve found a religious bond with your previous book I applauded. Especially as women who have a past when women from our cultures were treated differently. It’s still be happening around us but not as offensive as from when we first began in the word. The written word had been sacred and now that we have access to it we leave it out to dry, unless we want something. When we want something then were willing to do anything.
ReplyDeleteAlso im excited for your new journey! How far do you think this new journey will take you? Some people embark on journeys such as yours and don’t end up returning to their original state. They change as humans sometimes juristically. What do you expect to gain from this experience? Do you have a specific goal other to just being enlightened. There are many positive moments to gain from this but as far as negatives go what do you predict will be the me either shocking or disturbing find. When I say disturbing I mean as emotional disturbing. I know you aa a person and I feel that you’ll grow even more as a person.
-ali
I've never read the Freakonomics before, but after reading your blog I am very interested. It sounds like the kind of book you can just pick up at any time and learn something new and interesting from. Its really cool that you're going to read the Quran. I know very little about Islam and I'd be interested to hear about it. Its pretty crazy how people think they have an algorithm for finding out if someone is a terrorist or not. It seems like their would be a lot of generalizations and stereotypes involved in creating that algorithm. Just like you were saying, not all terrorists are Muslim and its silly to think that you can just make and algorithm to figure out who is a terrorist or not. People have different motives and come from different backgrounds. Not every terrorist is the same. I think its near impossible to create an algorithm to figure out who is a terrorist or not.
ReplyDelete